I definatly don't think Oscar is a shell of his former self, but I was never a big fan to begin with. In his losses PBF and Sugar Shane are just taylor made to beat him, Hopkins was way too big, In his wins Strum was 'overlooked', Chavez was ancient, the Tito fight still angers me to this day, and Vargas wasn't a real test no matter how he was pumped up by HBO. All in all he is a great fighter and champ just not one of the best of all time. He can still beat all but the best of the best out there right now. Cotto would be very interesting, moreso than a rematch with PBF.
|